All Posts

Retail Tech

Shopify, Toast and Square Results Show Merchants Are Really Buying a Processor

Shopify, Toast and Square Results Show Merchants Are Really Buying a Processor

TechShorts Newsroom

Editorial Team

Shopify, Toast and Block all reported third-quarter 2026 results on 3 November. They sell point-of-sale and commerce software to very different merchants, from online brands to restaurant groups. Read side by side, the three reports point to the same place these vendors earn most of their money, and it is not the monthly subscription.

We think that tells merchants how to buy. The subscription fee is the price on the pricing page. The processing contract is the price that grows with every sale, and it is the harder one to leave.

What the three reports show

Shopify reported revenue of $3.742 billion, up 32%, on gross merchandise volume of $119.1 billion, up 29%. Merchant solutions, the segment that includes Shopify Payments, brought in $2.906 billion, up 35%. Subscription solutions brought in $836 million, up 20%. Shopify Payments processed 68% of GMV in the quarter, against 65% a year earlier, according to an analysis of Shopify's filings.

Toast reported gross payment volume of $61.8 billion, up 20%, across approximately 189,000 locations. Financial technology revenue, which is mostly payments, was $1.619 billion, against $317 million from subscriptions. Most of that financial technology revenue goes back out as cost of revenue, $1.239 billion of it, so gross profit is the fairer comparison. On that measure, payments still earned Toast $311 million in the quarter, against $250 million from subscriptions.

Block's shareholder letter put Square gross payment volume at $76.4 billion, up 14%, with the fastest growth among mid-market sellers processing more than $500,000 a year. It also said that as of September only 16% of Square's US sellers used "monetized software". For the rest, processing is what Square charges for.

The software brings the processor with it

Toast and Shopify both tie the processor to the software, in different ways. Toast's own guide says Toast POS requires Toast Payments, which means "you can't shop for outside processing rates". Its earnings release notes one exception: select enterprise customers run Toast POS without Toast's payment services.

Shopify lets merchants use outside gateways, but it charges a third-party transaction fee on orders processed through them, even when Shopify Payments is also switched on. Orders paid through Shopify Payments or Shop Pay carry no such fee. Where Shopify Payments is available, the fee is not returned when an order is refunded. The fee does not apply to orders taken on Shopify's in-store POS.

Neither arrangement is hidden, and integration has real advantages. When the same vendor runs the terminal and the settlement, a merchant has a single support line and fewer reports to reconcile. Toast makes that case for its own model.

Where the growth is

The growth picture is less uniform than the revenue mix. At Shopify, merchant solutions grew 15 percentage points faster than subscriptions and is nearly three and a half times larger. At Toast it runs the other way: subscription gross profit rose about 41% from a year earlier and payments gross profit about 22%, as Toast sells more software into its base. Square's gross profit grew in line with its payment volume.

So the claim here is not that payments are always the faster line. It is that processing, or the segment built around it, is the larger line at Shopify and Toast. Wherever the processor comes bundled, it is also the stickier line, because changing it can mean changing the whole system.

What a merchant should price

If a vendor's economics sit in processing, a buyer's comparison should sit there too. A merchant comparing systems on monthly subscription cost is comparing the smaller line. The number worth modelling is the effective processing rate at the merchant's own expected volume, across the full contract term, plus any fee for using a different gateway.

The second number is the cost of leaving. Where the processor is mandatory, changing processor means changing the point-of-sale system, along with the staff routines and sales history built around it. That cost never appears on a quote, but it sets how much bargaining power the merchant has at renewal.

We think merchants should negotiate the processing rate before installation, not after. Before the system is live, walking away is cheap. Once staff are trained and the sales history lives in the vendor's system, every alternative costs more, and the vendor knows it.

What the filings do not settle

The filings cannot show how much of Shopify's rising payments share reflects merchants preferring its processor and how much reflects the fee attached to the alternatives. Nor do they show whether processing margins hold as more of Square's growth comes from larger sellers, who have more volume to bargain with.

What to watch

The holiday quarter is the next test. Toast has guided fourth-quarter non-GAAP subscription services and financial technology solutions gross profit to between $610 million and $620 million. Shopify expects fourth-quarter revenue to grow at a low-thirties percentage rate. Black Friday falls on 27 November, and the card volume that runs through these platforms that weekend will land in next quarter's payments lines.

Sources

  • Shopify. "Shopify Sustains Rapid Growth with Revenue Up 32% and Free Cash Flow Margin of 22% (Form 8-K, Exhibit 99.1)." 3 November 2026. https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/0001594805/000159480526000067/exhibit991pressreleaseq320.htm
  • sec-api.io. "Shopify (SHOP) Q3 2026 Earnings SEC Filing Analysis: $119bn GMV, 68% on Shopify Payments." 4 November 2026. https://sec-api.io/insights/shopify-shop-q3-2026-earnings-sec-filing-analysis-119bn-gmv-68-on-shopify-payments
  • Toast. "Toast Announces Third Quarter 2026 Financial Results (Form 8-K, Exhibit 99.1)." 3 November 2026. https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/0001650164/000165016426000214/tost-20260930xexhibit991.htm
  • Toast. "Toast Payment Processing: Rates, Features & How It Works." 22 June 2026. https://pos.toasttab.com/blog/on-the-line/toast-payment-processing
  • Block. "Q3 2026 Shareholder Letter." 3 November 2026. https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/0001512673/000162828026069513/q32026shareholderletter.htm
  • Shopify Help Center. "Third-party transaction fees on your Shopify bills." Accessed 8 November 2026. https://help.shopify.com/en/manual/your-account/manage-billing/billing-charges/types-of-charges/third-party-charges/third-party-transaction-fees
  • Shopify Help Center. "Third-party payment providers." Accessed 8 November 2026. https://help.shopify.com/en/manual/payments/third-party-providers