France's data protection authority has fined two Fnac Darty companies a combined €7 million because the retailer's mobile app kept sending user data to an outside domain after users refused tracking. The CNIL dated the decision 22 October and published it on 29 October.
In the same fortnight, EU governments agreed their position on cookie consent reform and Google told advertisers it will stop requiring hashed customer data in Google Ads Data Manager. The three developments are separate, but each turns on what happens to customer data after someone has made a choice about it.
France: a refusal inside an app has to stop the tracking
The CNIL's restricted committee fined Fnac Darty Participations et Services €6 million and Fnac Direct €1 million in decision SAN-2026-015 (CNIL, 2026). The case began with a complaint from the privacy group noyb, and the regulator inspected the Fnac app in March 2024.
After users refused non-essential trackers, the app still sent requests carrying a Fnac-assigned identifier and information on the user's activity, such as products viewed, to an outside domain (PPC Land, 2026). The tracker powered product recommendations and helped train the recommendation algorithm. The companies argued this was strictly necessary for a service the user had requested. The CNIL held that it fell outside the exemptions in Article 82 of the French Data Protection Act and needed prior consent.
The companies have one month from notification to show that their new tool obtains consent where required, or pay €10,000 for each day of delay. Fnac told AFP it contests the legal analysis, saying the features were product advice, not targeted advertising (AFP via Boursorama, 2026).
The CNIL's central point is that a refusal inside an app has to stop the tracking, not just change what the screen shows. Teams that run apps with recommendation or analytics SDKs should test the refusal path directly: refuse everything non-essential on a fresh install, browse, and check outbound traffic for identifiers or product events reaching third-party domains.
EU Council: more consent exemptions and a four-month re-ask wait
On 21 October, the Council of the EU agreed its negotiating position on the Digital Omnibus, the Commission's November 2025 proposal to simplify EU digital rules (Council of the EU, 2026). The Council keeps cookie rules in the ePrivacy Directive rather than moving them into the GDPR, and widens the circumstances in which consent is not required.
Reporting on the mandate text (Council document 14756/26) describes a closed list of six consent-free purposes, including the measurement of contextual advertising (PPC Land, 2026). After a refusal, a site would have to wait at least four months before asking again; the Commission had proposed six. The browser-level consent signal the Commission proposed in Article 88b is absent from the Council text.
The contextual exemption may be narrower than it sounds. PPC Land notes a tension in the text: a recital names "capping cookies" as an example of the measurement covered, while the operative article bars processing of data about a user's past or future activity. One reading is that counting impressions of one campaign on one service is not "activity" in that sense, but the text leaves that to regulators.
None of this is law. Talks with the European Parliament start only once Parliament adopts its own position, and current consent rules apply in the meantime. The useful preparation is an inventory of which cookies and tags serve which purpose, so the team can see which ones a surviving exemption would cover.
Google: Data Manager stops requiring SHA-256 hashing on 16 November
In an email to advertisers, Google said: "Starting on November 16, 2026, we will no longer require hashed customer data (SHA-256) for Google Ads Data Manager and will instead support encrypted customer data by default" (PPC Land, 2026). The change covers Customer Match and enhanced conversions, and the email names CRM connections, cloud storage imports, direct file uploads and the Data Manager API as covered routes.
Google will decrypt and match the data inside a trusted execution environment, the setup behind the confidential matching it made the default for Customer Match connections in 2024 (Google, 2024). What changes is that advertisers no longer have to reduce identifiers to hashes before upload, and formatting moves to Google's side. PPC Land infers from the email's "decrypts, normalizes, and matches" sequence that readable email addresses and phone numbers would exist inside that environment during processing. Google does not say so directly.
Several points are unresolved. The email does not say whether uploads that already send SHA-256 hashes will keep working unchanged, or whether advertisers can choose to keep sending hashes only. The public copy, posted on LinkedIn on 18 October, is undated. PPC Land also notes that some data protection assessments of Customer Match were written on the basis that only hashed values left the advertiser.
Marketing operations teams should record current match rates in Data Manager before 16 November so any shift afterwards is visible. They should also ask Google whether scheduled hashed uploads continue as they are. Privacy teams should check any impact assessment or processing record that describes these uploads as hashed.
What to watch
Google's change takes effect on 16 November. The first test is whether Google documents what happens to hashed uploads before then. The Fnac companies can appeal to the Conseil d'État within two months of notification, according to PPC Land. On the Digital Omnibus, the next step is the European Parliament's position, including whether MEPs try to restore the browser signal.
Sources
- CNIL. "Cookies and mobile application: 7 million euros fine against FNAC DARTY PARTICIPATIONS ET SERVICES and FNAC DIRECT." 2026. https://www.cnil.fr/en/sanction-app-cookies-fnac
- PPC Land. "CNIL fines Fnac €7m after its app tracked users who refused consent." 2026. https://ppc.land/cnil-fines-fnac-eur7m-after-its-app-tracked-users-who-refused-consent/
- AFP via Boursorama. "Données personnelles : la Cnil inflige une amende de 7 millions d'euros à Fnac Darty." 2026. https://www.boursorama.com/bourse/actualites/donnees-personnelles-la-cnil-inflige-une-amende-de-7-millions-d-euros-a-fnac-darty-184a2ce1c0c8d9d98f3edb3964b81b26
- Council of the EU. "Digital rulebook: Council agrees position to simplify data protection, privacy and cyber reporting rules." 2026. https://www.consilium.europa.eu/en/press/press-releases/2026/10/21/digital-rulebook-council-agrees-position-to-simplify-data-protection-privacy-and-cyber-reporting-rules/
- PPC Land. "EU Council agrees 4-month cookie re-ask wait for Digital Omnibus talks." 2026. https://ppc.land/eu-council-agrees-4-month-cookie-re-ask-wait-for-digital-omnibus-talks/
- PPC Land. "EU Council text lists 6 cookie purposes that would need no consent." 2026. https://ppc.land/eu-council-text-lists-6-cookie-purposes-that-would-need-no-consent/
- PPC Land. "Google Ads Data Manager stops requiring hashed customer data November 16." 2026. https://ppc.land/google-ads-data-manager-stops-requiring-hashed-customer-data-november-16/
- Google. "Simpler data privacy for advertisers with confidential matching." 2024. https://blog.google/products/ads-commerce/google-confidential-matching-data-privacy/
