All Posts

FinTech

Canada's Real-Time Rail Starts Without Big Banks as EU Moves to Drop FiDA

Canada's Real-Time Rail Starts Without Big Banks as EU Moves to Drop FiDA

TechShorts Newsroom

Editorial Team

Canada's Real-Time Rail went live on 9 November with eight participants, and none of them is one of the country's Big Six banks. In the same week, the European Commission listed its open finance proposal for withdrawal, and the Reserve Bank of India folded its cyber security rules for non-bank payment firms into a single rulebook. The three decisions are unrelated and do not point the same way, but each sets terms for how firms that are not banks connect to core financial infrastructure.

Canada: smaller players went first

The Real-Time Rail clears and settles payments 24 hours a day, every day of the year, Payments Canada said at launch. The first participants are Wealthsimple, KOHO, Questbank, Peoples Trust Company, Paramount Commerce, DoBusiness.com, Digital Commerce Bank and Bank of America. Payments Canada says more participants, including all major Canadian financial institutions, will onboard in the coming months.

The list reflects an access change made earlier this year. In January 2026, after amendments to the Canadian Payments Act widened eligibility, Payments Canada admitted five payment service providers as members, including KOHO and Paramount Commerce (Fintech.ca). To qualify, a payment service provider must first register with the Bank of Canada under the Retail Payment Activities Act (Payments Canada).

Access comes with conditions. Every participant must use four centralised fraud services: confirmation of payee, a real-time risk score on every transaction, a shared list of accounts linked to confirmed fraud, and a fraud reporting and intelligence platform (Payments Canada). Payments Canada says this makes Canada the first G7 country to launch a real-time system with mandatory centralised fraud services. Its FAQ sets an initial system transaction limit of $100,000, to be reassessed after launch.

The immediate effect is limited. Both the sending and the receiving institution must be on the rail for an instant payment, and the Big Six are not on it yet. KOHO chief executive Daniel Eberhard has told BetaKit that the rail would be largely performative without them. Wealthsimple says it is testing the system and plans to roll out client features built on it in 2027 (iPhone in Canada).

EU: open finance loses its legislative vehicle

The Commission adopted its 2027 work programme on 4 November. Its withdrawals annex lists 18 pending proposals it intends to withdraw within six months, and the Financial Data Access regulation, known as FiDA, is one of them. The Commission's stated reason is that the file has been pending for more than three years, no trilogues have taken place since June 2025, and it is unlikely to win support in the Council within a reasonable timeframe.

The Commission proposed FiDA in June 2023. It would have let customers have financial firms share data on their mortgages and loans, savings and investments, pension rights and non-life insurance with authorised third parties (Norton Rose Fulbright). That would have taken the open banking model beyond payment accounts. A leaked draft of the Commission's 2025 work programme had also listed FiDA for withdrawal, but the published version kept it as a pending proposal.

The German insurers' association GDV and the cooperative banks' association BVR welcomed the decision, trade publication Cash.Online reported. Citing Börsen-Zeitung, the same outlet reported that the European FinTech Association deeply regretted it, arguing that a broad rollout of open finance would have noticeably lifted the EU economy.

Payment account data is unaffected. Third-party access to it sits in PSD2 today and carries into the Payment Services Regulation, on which Parliament and Council reached a provisional agreement on 27 November 2025 (Taylor Wessing). That agreement includes a list of prohibited barriers to data access and a dashboard for customers to manage the permissions they have granted. What lapses with FiDA is the plan to extend that model to mortgage, investment, pension and insurance data.

India: one rulebook for non-bank payment operators

On 5 November, the RBI issued consolidated Master Directions on cyber resilience and digital payment security controls for non-bank payment system operators. They apply to NPCI, which runs UPI, as well as card networks, payment aggregators, prepaid payment instrument issuers and white-label ATM operators, among others (Business Standard). The directions build on the RBI's July 2024 rules, fold in its 2019 controls for third-party ATM switch providers and its 2020 system audit requirements, and repeal six circulars issued between 2009 and 2020 (Medianama).

Much of the substance carries over. The six-hour window for reporting cyber incidents to the RBI stays, as does a minimum 12-hour wait before online payments after a customer changes a registered mobile number or email. The rules apply to large and medium operators immediately, and small operators have until 1 April 2028 (Vinod Kothari Consultants).

Outlook Money described the requirements on software security, system audits and third-party providers as stricter. Operators must obtain the source code of critical applications bought from third parties, or hold it in escrow where that is not possible. Annual system audits must cover 20 areas, with reports due to the RBI within two months of the end of the financial year, which means by 1 June for operators on an April to March year.

What the three decisions show

Canada widened who can connect directly to its national rail and attached mandatory fraud controls to that access. In India, where a non-bank already runs UPI, the RBI left access unchanged and gathered security obligations into one document. The EU, meanwhile, stepped back from requiring incumbents to share more customer data with new entrants.

There is no single global direction here. The narrower common thread is that each authority is settling what non-banks must accept in exchange for access and, in the EU's case, what incumbents owe them.

What to watch

  • Onboarding dates for the Big Six banks, against Payments Canada's target of reaching more than nine in 10 Canadians within a year of launch.
  • The Commission's formal withdrawal decision on FiDA, due within six months of 4 November, and whether any replacement open finance proposal follows.
  • The first annual system audit reports under the consolidated RBI directions, due by 1 June 2027 for operators on an April to March year.

Sources

  • Payments Canada. "Canada launches the Real-Time Rail, bringing 24/7 payment infrastructure to the national economy." 9 November 2026. https://www.payments.ca/canada-launches-real-time-rail-bringing-247-payment-infrastructure-national-economy
  • Payments Canada. "Fraud services." Accessed November 2026. https://www.payments.ca/systems-services/payment-systems/real-time-rail-payment-system/fraud-services
  • Payments Canada. "Frequently asked questions." Accessed November 2026. https://www.payments.ca/systems-services/payment-systems/real-time-rail-payment-system/frequently-asked-questions
  • BetaKit. "Canada's long-awaited Real-Time Rail payments system launches without Big Six banks." 9 November 2026. https://betakit.com/canadas-long-awaited-real-time-rail-payments-system-launches-without-big-six-banks/
  • Fintech.ca. "Brim, Float, Koho, Paramount, and Wise Join Payments Canada." 27 January 2026. https://www.fintech.ca/2026/01/27/payments-canada-welcomes-five-new-fintech-psp-members/
  • iPhone in Canada. "Wealthsimple Joins Canada's Real-Time Rail as Instant Payments Go Live." 9 November 2026. https://www.iphoneincanada.ca/2026/11/09/wealthsimple-real-time-rail-launch/
  • European Commission. "2027 Commission work programme and annexes." 4 November 2026. https://commission.europa.eu/publications/2027-commission-work-programme-and-annexes_en
  • Norton Rose Fulbright. "From open banking to open finance: FiDA." Accessed November 2026. https://www.nortonrosefulbright.com/en/knowledge/publications/b029b764/from-open-banking-to-open-finance-fida
  • Cash.Online. "EU-Kommission will FiDA zurückziehen: Was das für Versicherer, Banken und Vermittler heißt." 5 November 2026. https://www.cash-online.de/a/eu-kommission-zieht-fida-verordnung-zurueck-folgen-fuer-versicherer-und-banken-729527/
  • Taylor Wessing. "EU lawmakers strike a deal on payments reforms." 1 December 2025. https://www.taylorwessing.com/en/insights-and-events/insights/2025/11/eu-lawmakers-strike-a-deal-on-payments-reforms
  • Reserve Bank of India. "Master Directions on Cyber Resilience and Digital Payment Security Controls for non-bank Payment System Operators." 5 November 2026. https://rbi.org.in/Scripts/NotificationUser.aspx?Id=13751&Mode=0
  • Business Standard. "RBI tightens cyber oversight of non-bank payment system operators." 5 November 2026. https://www.business-standard.com/industry/banking/rbi-consolidates-cyber-security-rules-for-non-bank-payment-system-operators-126110502060_1.html
  • Medianama. "Lowdown: What RBI's consolidated cyber security rules mean for payment apps and users." 9 November 2026. https://www.medianama.com/2026/11/223-rbi-cyber-security-rules-payment-companies/
  • Vinod Kothari Consultants. "RBI's Consolidated Master Directions on Cyber Resilience and Digital Payment Security Controls for Non-bank Payment System Operators." 10 November 2026. https://vinodkothari.com/2026/11/rbis-consolidated-master-directions-on-cyber-resilience-and-digital-payment-security-controls-for-non-bank-payment-system-operators/
  • Outlook Money. "RBI Issues New Cyber Security Rules For Non-Bank Payment Operators, Sets Audit Deadlines." 6 November 2026. https://www.outlookmoney.com/banking/rbi-issues-new-cyber-security-rules-for-non-bank-payment-operators-sets-audit-deadlines